CHAPTER 18
Materials: towards a circular economy
The earth consists of a large array of elements, neatly represented in the periodic table, which are chemically or otherwise bonded in natural and human-intervened stocks and flows.
- Some elements and compounds are sequestered for long periods; others are more mobile. From a sustainability perspective, the anthropogenic flows relative to the natural flows is an indicator of degree of human intervention.For some (C, P, N, Mg), even massive intervention is minor compared to natural flows; for others (Pt, Au, Sn, W) human exploitation is a significant fraction of natural flows;
- Similar to fossil fuel use, the production of materials has increased exponentially in the last century, exceeding nowadays 70 Gt/yr, of which 40% are construction materials and another 40% biomass-related. Flows of ores and industrial minerals are much smaller (~ 5 Gt/yr, roughly half the size of fossil fuel mass flows) but of higher value and more widely used. Productivity in aggregate material use per unit of economic output has risen.
- Materials are part of commodity or supply chains, which are investigated in Material Flow Analyses (MFA) and input-output (I-O analysis. The resulting consumption-based indicator is called, in analogy with water and carbon, the material footprint(MF) for a country or region. The inclusion of trade flows can give a significantly different outcome.
- Commodity chains consist of stocks (ore deposit, in-use and end-of-life) which are connected by flows (mining output, discard rate etc.). A key indicator from a sustainability source and sink perspective is the fraction of throughput which ends up in the environment in too diluted form to be recovered or reused (dissipation rate). It differs widely for different elements.
- Commodity chains are confronted with depletion and cause environmental harm. The prime activity to mitigate both is to stimulate redesign, reuse and recycling. Another option, often occurring unintentionally, is the use of substitutes. An over-all scarcity index should contain both dissipation rate and substitution potential. Many analyses have been done to assess the scarcity of ‘critical’ materials (Ag, Co, In, Pt, Ni, Cr, Mo, rare earth, Cu, Cr, Pb…).
- The available resource is another indicator of scarcity. However, impending scarcity has historically for many elements been postponed by new discoveries by the few, globally operating corporations. However, mining has serious environmental implications, which become more serious obstacles with tighter environmental regulation and more ambitious preservation and bioreserves targets.
- Chemical substances are at the core of environmental pollution – and science – since they have been shown to cause all kinds of harm to human and ecosystem health. In particular the emissions of persistent chemicals need (more) research and regulation. Unfortunately, the number of new chemical compounds still grows and a large fraction is not (yet) classified.
- A key material in Modernity is plastic, an umbrella term for a range of (semi-)synthetic polymers. Their use has grown exponentially since mid-20th century and is expected to keep growing. Like metals, their manufacturing requires a lot of energy (partly as feedstock) and their persistence and high dissipation rate are reason for alarm and urgent action.
Test your understanding of this chapter by reviewing the study questions below.
All Materials Relevant to this Chapter
Richer ánd cleaner? Is there an Environmental Kuznets Curve?
One unsustainable part of the industrial economy is the mining and processing of materials and fuels which creates also large flows of ‘waste’ and burdens environmental sinks. Upstream, huge amounts of solid waste are generated [...]
The idea of ‘waste’
What is waste? A friend once took me to the urban waste treatment plant in Kolkata and I had the strange experience of looking into the stomach and intestines of a huge organism. Across an enormous [...]
Materials Transition
Conceptual framework The gradual change from mining ores to mining in-use-stocks can be considered a materials transition. The ratios between metal in the lithosphere, in in-use stocks and in end-of-lifetime stocks are indicators of the [...]
Depletion dynamics: Oil in the USA and gas in the Netherlands
Models of oil and gas exploitation An important issue in sustainable development discourses is the depletion of finite resources of fossil fuels and minerals. The concepts of supply cost curves and reserve-production ratios (RPR) have [...]
Resource scarcity: the Crustal Abundance Geostatistical (CAG) model
In the context of sustainable development, the emphasis is usually on depletion and a key question is: How big is the resource or, in expert jargon, what is the geological resource base? First, I look [...]
Forests in Japanese history
Forests in Japan have been under pressure already for millennia (Totman 1989). More than 2000 years ago, rice culture caused the first dramatic modifications of woodlands and bronze and iron smelting started to put pressure [...]
The Utrecht Griftpark: the Dynamism of Environmental Pollution
On the eastside of Utrecht, there is a large area with a lake, a playground, trees, statues, an animal farm. It’s a very enjoyable place for all kinds of people and activities. Yet, only 60 [...]
Nauru: phosphate, fish, money and refugees on a 21st century Easter Island? *
Some 1500 km east of Papua New Guinea, in the Pacific, is the small island of Nauru. It is the smallest independent republic, with nowadays some 12.000 inhabitants on an area of less than 25 [...]
Mining in Papua New Guinea
Papua New Guinea is one of the world's largest island. Called the ‘Last Great Place’, it is home to hundreds of unique species of animals and plants as well as to upward of 820 languages. [...]